logo

57 pages 1 hour read

Last Night at the Telegraph Club

Fiction | Novel | YA | Published in 2021

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Grace and Part 2Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 2: “I Enjoy Being a Girl: October to November 1954”

Part 2, Chapter 10 Summary

At school, Lily and Shirley look through job brochures in preparation for a report on careers for their class. Shirley bemoans the fact that a member of the dance committee had to drop out. Seeing this as a way to avoid Will, Lily volunteers.

Shirley fills her in on what’s needed for the dance. Then, Lily asks about the picnic they attended and Calvin. Shirley says that her parents told her not to go to any more of them. Lily adds that the government is using Communism as an excuse to deport Chinese Americans.

After they eat lunch, Shirley tells Lily that she didn’t have to join the committee to avoid Will and that she wouldn’t have made her go to the dance with him.

Later, Lily looks through the pamphlet she found warning against Communism. However, she’s somewhat drawn to the section that outlines Communism’s greatest strength, which is to make people feel like they should take control over others, and states that it encourages this desire. Within this explanation, “[f]our words seemed to rise up off the page in whispers: secret, lust, natural, try” (91).

She decides to ask Kath to go with her the next day to the drugstore to see the novel Strange Season.

Part 2, Chapter 11 Summary

The next day, at the store, the book isn’t there, and Kath asks what it was about. They still haven’t talked about the Telegraph Club, and Lily hoped that the book would embody some of her questions. Eventually, Lily explains the plot and asks, “Have you ever heard of such a thing?” (93). Kath hesitates, and Lily’s heart thunders in her chest. Then, Kath says, “Yes.”

They leave the drugstore, and Lily explains more about the story, asking if Kath has met women “like that.” Kath’s friend Jean, who went to the Telegraph Club, is lesbian. So is everyone there, Kath says, except perhaps for the tourists.

A man whistles at them, commenting inappropriately about how he likes Chinese women. Lily grabs Kath’s hand and they quickly move away from him. Now in Chinatown, Lily feels like she can’t return to discussing the Telegraph Club. They decide to get ginger ice cream.

Part 2, Chapter 12 Summary

Lily wonders what Kath thinks of Chinatown, feeling self-conscious. She has never been to Fong Fong’s—the ice cream shop—with someone white. As they wait for their ice cream, Lily asks if Kath is going to the fall dance. Kath isn’t sure since she doesn’t like dances, and Lily explains that she joined the dance committee only to avoid having to go with Wil. Kath agrees to go if Lily agrees to go to another club meeting. Lily talks about how she wishes there were a women’s science club since she doesn’t want to be the only girl in the science club at school. Then, she transitions to how she wants to work on rockets.

Eventually, Kath agrees to go to the dance, and Lily says she’ll go bowling with the G.A.A. They shake hands, and Lily thinks about how she wants to ask whether Kath is interested in women because Lily thinks she is.

Part 2, Chapter 13 Summary

On the day of the dance, Lily helps set up, arriving hours before the start time. She worries that Kath won’t come to the dance and what that would mean. When it starts, Lily works the refreshment table, watching Shirley convince people to dance by dancing with Will. She notices that the Chinese students are dancing with each other, the Black students with each other, etc. As the night goes on, Lily is freed from her role at the drink table. Popular music plays, and others dance. Finally, she spots Kath, who touches her arm. They leave.

Part 2, Chapter 14 Summary

They decide to walk to Aquatic Park. Kath apologizes that she was unable to arrive sooner. Lily brushes it off, saying that she’s happy Kath came. At they walk, Lily gets cold, and Kath gives Lily her jacket. It’s a foggy night, and Lily feels that they’re obscured by the fog. She decides to ask about the Telegraph Club. Kath describes seeing Tommy Andrews, and Lily wishes she could go. Kath suggests that they should. Lily resists at first, and Kath asks how old she is before offering to get her a fake ID since she’d have to be 18. She says she’ll ask Jean how to get one when she’s in town next weekend. Lily is thrilled, but they decide to go back to the dance when Lily sees Kath shiver.

Part 2, Chapter 15 Summary

Seeing Lily and Kath approach, Shirley wants Lily to return to the refreshment table, and Kath goes home. Shirley pulls Lily aside and warns her about Kath because the year before, Jean was caught in the band room with another girl.

Lily is shocked that Shirley knows who Jean is. She then remembers that Calvin once started dating an African American girl, which was scandalous. Shirley recommends staying away from Kath to avoid starting any rumors, and Lily asks her if Calvin was the one who told her about Jean. Shirley avoids answering and then suggests that Lily dance with Will in case anyone saw her with Kath.

Growing bold, Lily asserts that Shirley shouldn’t talk about her with Will and that nothing is wrong with Kath. Protesting, Shirley insists that she’s trying to help, but Lily rebukes her and decides to leave.

Part 2, Chapter 16 Summary

On Monday morning, Shirley doesn’t walk to school with Lily, and she quickly notices that Will is also ignoring her. When she arrives at school, she calls out to Kath, and they walk to class together. Kath is surprised that she isn’t walking with Shirley but seems happy to have Lily’s company.

Part 2, Chapter 17 Summary

Lily holds up her end of the deal, going bowling with the G.A.A. She has never been bowling before, and Kath teaches her how to throw the ball. Lily eventually notices a group of men looking at the girls as they toss the ball down the lane, their skirts rising ever so slightly. Kath says to ignore them, but they don’t resume bowling. Instead, Lily explains the physics behind bowling, and then the two discuss what it would be like to ride on a rocket. When Kath resumes bowling, Lily blocks the men’s view.

Part 2, Chapter 18 Summary

The following week, Kath stops at Lily’s locker first thing on Monday, saying that she has Lily’s fake ID. She gives it to her after school. The ID reads “May Lee Wong,” and Lily is slightly nervous about getting caught. She also wonders if it’s as easy to fake immigration papers, thinking of her father. Lily asks if the ID will work, and Kath says that the only way to know is to go to the Telegraph Club. They decide to go on Friday night.

At home, Lily looks again at the Tommy Anderson ad, not quite believing that she’ll soon see the act live. She falls asleep, dreaming of a rocket but unsure where it’s heading.

Grace and Part 2 Analysis

In this section, Lily and Kath grow closer. Strange Seasons reappears, and Lily uses it as a way to communicate with Kath, the only person in her life she can talk to about the book. Because being gay is such a taboo topic, neither is willing to explicitly admit that their conversations are about more than women interested in women. Lily feels more confident that she’s like the women in the book, and Kath becomes an outlet for this interest given her familiarity with the Telegraph Club. Slowly, she works toward being honest with Kath.

However, Lily still feels nervous about bringing Kath into Chinatown, having to balance her feelings of belonging around Kath with her intersectional identity. Chinese immigrants and Chinse Americans are treated as second-class citizens, largely because of racism spurred on by US conflicts with Asian countries like Japan, Korea, and China during the mid-20th century.

Part of this systemic racism plays into the theme Being a “Good” Chinese American Citizen. Racial mixing was heavily discouraged during this time, especially as it was before Loving v. Virginia (1967), a Supreme Court case that struck down laws banning marriage between people of different races. The novel reflects this in revealing that Calvin’s being seen with an African American girl was scandalous. Likewise, Shirley warns Lily of another prejudice when she notes that it would be scandalous for Lily to associate with someone who was lesbian. However, Lily stands up for her friendship with Kath, knowing that she herself may be scorned by society for yet another reason besides her race.

At the end of the section, as Lily prepares to go to the Telegraph Club with Kath, she looks again at the Tommy Anderson photo, a recurring symbol throughout the novel. Both the image and the club symbolize hope, and especially after talking with Kath so much about the club and beginning deeper conversations about being lesbian, Lily is hopeful about what she’ll find at the club, thinking that she’ll finally be with people like herself.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
Unlock IconUnlock all 57 pages of this Study Guide

Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.

Including features:

+ Mobile App
+ Printable PDF
+ Literary AI Tools